Page 1 of 1

Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Posted: January 13 26, 4:30 pm
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on January 13. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

A lot of good questions this week, but no bonus Q&As this time. Enjoy anyway!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/chat-with ... 23510.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think Colin Rea gets traded to a club that needs pitching now that he is on the outside of the Cubs rotation?

Steve Adams
Rea signed as a free agent, meaning he can't be traded without his consent until June 15. This is his second straight one-year deal with the Cubs, and he's a midwest guy who wants to be in the midwest. He's not getting traded. He'll be in a swing role, which is surely fine with him. He's used to it. And with injuries, he'll probably still start 10+ games (as long as he remains healthy himself).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Assuming St Louis can't trade Arenado, why not take a page from the Angels book and defer the remaining contract over 3 or 4 years and cut him loose?

Steve Adams
One of the very earliest questions from this morning, ha. What a difference a few hours makes!
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Where is Tucker playing next season?

Steve Adams
Where will Kyle Tucker be playing in 2026?

Mets (40.5% | 527 votes)

Dodgers (13.7% | 178 votes)

Blue Jays (29.7% | 386 votes)

Yankees (4.7% | 61 votes)

Elsewhere (11.4% | 148 votes)

Total Votes: 1,300

For the record, my vote in that Tucker poll was also for the Jays.
So I am with the majority here, it seems.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on the Nolan Arenado trade?

Steve Adams
It's about what I expected. The Cardinals ate 70% of the money and got basically no return. Arenado at two years and $11MM is a fine value for the D-backs. It works for all parties.
Also, not trying to disparage Jack Martinez there, but he was an eighth-round senior sign who took below slot value last summer in the draft. He's not a big get for the Cardinals. Hopefully they can turn him into something, but this trade was about clearing as much cash as possible and putting Arenado in a spot that's better for him, his family, and his career goals.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Phillies should sign Bichette and trade Bohm to the Angels, unless Bichette's defense wouldn't offset his offense.

Steve Adams
This scenario makes perfect sense to me, and I think Bichette would be fine at either second base or third base (though for arm strength purposes, the former seems a better fit).
Pirates make some sense for Bohm, too.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pirates are in on Lawler? Is he a better bet than Vientos?

Steve Adams
Both seem like reasonable targets, although I will say, Lawlar does not seem like he's going to be a capable 3B defender. That's also probably true of Vientos, though.

Both are more along the lines of the Jhostynxon Garcia addition -- high-upside, limited/no MLB track record -- than the type of more established bats the Pirates were hoping to acquire though.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does Sal Stewart break camp with the Reds?

Steve Adams
That's my expectation.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Re: Nico Hoerner's availability - would you expect it to cost the Yankees the same player cost as Bellinger last year?

Steve Adams
No way. The Cubs were trying to dump Bellinger's salary and took almost no return. Hoerner has immense surplus value and would cost immediate, meaningful major league help.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
We keep hearing the Mets are focused more on the trade side for starting pitching. Give me a few players besides Peralta that are legitimate options.

Steve Adams
Freddy Peralta, MacKenzie Gore, Kris Bubic, Jose Berrios, Brady Singer, maybe Nick Pivetta. I could see one of Andrew Abbott or Nick Lodolo if they send the right bat back to Cincinnati. Mitch Keller. Kyle Freeland.

Obviously not all great names, and the Mets probably aren't interested in adding more back-of-the-rotation types, but just running through some names off the cuff. I'm sure with a big enough offer you could get the Twins to reconsider their "We're not trading Joe Ryan or Pablo Lopez" stance.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Gaddis for Hoerner?

Steve Adams
Cubs wouldn't do that.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Nats shock everyone and sign Tucker to a 11 year deal, leading the rebuild - Jayson Werth 2.0!

Steve Adams
Won't happen, but as a perpetual advocate for unmitigated baseball chaos, let me go on record as saying "Yes please."
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Skubal wins his arb case, this surely increases the likelihood that the Pirates trade Skenes this offseason, right? if the Pirates underperform this season, this bumps up even more to the trade deadline. There's no way they start paying him $30M+ this early in his career.

Steve Adams
I don't think so. Skubal is only able to even attempt this "blow up the arb system" because he has 5+ years of service. Skenes will set records in arb but do so more incrementally. Pirates will probably still trade him at some point... but probably not for another three years.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Your latest guess on who Peralta gets traded to or do you think he remains a Brewer?

Steve Adams
I lean toward him staying, but if I'm forced to pick a team that trades for him, I'd lean Mets.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is it safe to say that William Contreras is upset with the Brewers for lowballing him?

Steve Adams
No. This is just arbitration.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With Tucker now being open to a 3 year 40m AAV deal, do you think it's an overall league trend to do inflated AAV contracts instead of longer deals with multiple down years in late 30s?

Steve Adams
Just because that's where the Mets' offer is does not mean that he's necessarily open to it. Plus, multiple reports during this chat have said that their offer is actually worth more than $50MM annually. Let's get weird!
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does the addition of Arenado to the Diamondbacks put trading Marte back on the table?

Steve Adams
No. They got Arenado for the price of basically a middle reliever.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Rules question: if the White Sox signed Tucker, would they lose the #1 pick?

Steve Adams
Here you go:
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/10/ ... agent.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Tucker is not worth $50M AAV.

Steve Adams
The Mets agree! They'd be paying a 110% tax on his contract's AAV, so they think he's worth $100MM+ annually.
-----------------------------------------------------------------