Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments
Posted: January 20 26, 7:18 pm
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on January 18.
Just about the same amount of questions this week, and one bonus question about a facet of a salary cap that I haven't seen addressed before. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/01/ ... t-101.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Freddy Peralta for River Ryan and Eduardo Quintero. Who says no?
Mark Polishuk
Brewers, without hesitation.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Matt Shaw to St. Louis for Brendan Donovan. Who says no?
Mark Polishuk
The Cubs, since I think they value Shaw more highly than two years of Donovan. Also, the chances of a Chicago/St. Louis trade of this magnitude are very, very low.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Most likely to move: Peralta, Gore, Lodolo or Bubic?
Mark Polishuk
Just my two cents, but from most to least, I’d rank them Bubic, Peralta, Gore, Lodolo.
The Reds’ rotation is such their bread-and-butter that I don’t see them moving any of their big three. Gore is probably staying put this offseason, but the trade deadline could be a different story.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think the Reds trade Brady Singer? He’s only under contract for 1 more season before hitting FA. I would think the Reds would like to get something in return for him.
Mark Polishuk
He has long seemed like the most logical Reds starter to be on the move, but no deal to date. Doesn’t mean a trade couldn’t still happen in the next few weeks, but it’d be interesting to see what kind of significant bat (if any) the Reds could acquire for one season of a solid starter but one who probably projects as a back-end starter on a good team
In general, Singer isn’t the type of pitcher who’s a lock to start a playoff game. Teams are only willing to give up so much for such a player.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Blue Jays have any interest in a Brendon Donovan/ Jojo Romero swap?
Mark Polishuk
Both would fit in Toronto, but the Jays have enough utility infield types that Donovan probably isn’t a priority (and especially not at the Cardinals’ asking price). Romero would be the better fit of the two.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pirates finished with 71 wins last year with barely any hitters over 100 wRC+. Adding in O'Hearn and Lowe should really help them. Could they realistically content for a WC spot and if not, what is holding them back?
Mark Polishuk
I think they’ve got a decent shot at a wild card as presently constructed. I’d like to see one more notable bat added to really spark things upwards, however.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Isn’t this a good time for Cards to rebuild – especially with the potential stoppage?
Mark Polishuk
Last year seemed like an even better team for the Cardinals to rebuild, yet they didn’t. Notwithstanding how their hands were tied by some no-trade clauses, it still makes me scratch my head about how even guys like Helsley, etc. weren’t dealt last winter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Chances Hoerner gets moved this offseason?
Mark Polishuk
Pretty low. The Cubs aren’t moving him unless they get a huge offer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How high of a ranked prospect will the Red Sox need to add to trade Yoshida?
Mark Polishuk
Considering those trades with the Cardinals, I wonder if the timing had worked out better (i.e. if Contreras had been more willing to waive his no-trade clause earlier), if Yoshida could’ve just been dealt to St. Louis as salary offset as part of a package for both Gray and Contreras. Probably still no, since while the Cards were eating money in the trades anyway, they still wanted players back.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see the Pirates moving Henry Davis or Endy Rodriguez to one of these catcher needy teams?
Mark Polishuk
Endy is the likelier of the two, just because the Pirates might not be able to bring themselves to move a 1-1 player just yet.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
SF Giant suggestion: trade Heliot Ramos and his horrible defense to STL for Donovan. Sign Bellinger and Bader to fix that outfield D, and still stay under the tax. Thoughts?
Mark Polishuk
Ramos probably isn’t the kind of player St. Louis is targeting in Donovan trade talks.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Seen some Cardinals fans hoping for Marcelo Mayer as part of a Brendan Donovan return. Unrealistic, no?
Mark Polishuk
Very.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
McCutcheon still wants to finish his career as a Pirate. Is he not worthy anymore?
Mark Polishuk
It’s tricky because Cutch is such a legend and so beloved in Pittsburgh. But in terms of what a player can produce in 2026 or how much playing time he should get, it’s tough to argue apart from pure sentiment that McCutchen should be part of a team serious about winning.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Feels like Padres are in a good spot to try and move Cronenworth with Hoerner/Marte both seeming unlikely to move.
Mark Polishuk
Cronenworth’s contract is a huge negative in trade talks. Hoerner is just for one year and Marte is a superstar, so they both have way more trade value.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Hoyer said at Cubs Con that they weren’t done yet. Bellinger?
Mark Polishuk
To be fair, it would’ve been pretty unlikely to see Hoyer stand up in front of a crowd of Cubs fans and announce “that’s it! I’m going on vacation!” and then run offstage with an overstuffed suitcase.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
As a Reds fan, I wouldn’t be on board with this, but I’ve seen multiple fellow Reds fans recommend dealing Brady Singer and Tyler Stephenson for Jarren Duran. Is that something Boston would even consider? Feels very light to me when you consider years of control and Duran’s ceiling.
Mark Polishuk
Boston definitely wants a lot more than that for Duran.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Andrew Vaughn is a free agent after this season. Do you think the Brewers resign him or let him walk?
Mark Polishuk
Probably let him walk. The Brewers aren’t likely to spend a significant amount on the first base position.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With a few hall of fame careers winding down, where does Jr Griffey place on your top 10-15 of all time list?
Mark Polishuk
I wouldn’t have Griffey in my top 10-15, but he’s not far outside that range.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Suppose the owners get their salary cap. What happens to contracts like Ohtani’s, Soto’s, etc? Would they be grandfathered in and the Dodgers and Mets would just be mostly unable to sign free agents until they come off the books?
Mark Polishuk
As noted earlier, if the MLBPA did somehow agree to any sort of a cap, it would be a soft cap with some sort of luxury tax still attached for overages. So depending on how stiff the penalties are, the Dodgers/Mets/etc. could decide they don’t really care about the penalties and keep spending big.
But, the league would certainly create a year or two of grace period for teams to get under this new cap.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Just about the same amount of questions this week, and one bonus question about a facet of a salary cap that I haven't seen addressed before. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/01/ ... t-101.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Freddy Peralta for River Ryan and Eduardo Quintero. Who says no?
Mark Polishuk
Brewers, without hesitation.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Matt Shaw to St. Louis for Brendan Donovan. Who says no?
Mark Polishuk
The Cubs, since I think they value Shaw more highly than two years of Donovan. Also, the chances of a Chicago/St. Louis trade of this magnitude are very, very low.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Most likely to move: Peralta, Gore, Lodolo or Bubic?
Mark Polishuk
Just my two cents, but from most to least, I’d rank them Bubic, Peralta, Gore, Lodolo.
The Reds’ rotation is such their bread-and-butter that I don’t see them moving any of their big three. Gore is probably staying put this offseason, but the trade deadline could be a different story.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think the Reds trade Brady Singer? He’s only under contract for 1 more season before hitting FA. I would think the Reds would like to get something in return for him.
Mark Polishuk
He has long seemed like the most logical Reds starter to be on the move, but no deal to date. Doesn’t mean a trade couldn’t still happen in the next few weeks, but it’d be interesting to see what kind of significant bat (if any) the Reds could acquire for one season of a solid starter but one who probably projects as a back-end starter on a good team
In general, Singer isn’t the type of pitcher who’s a lock to start a playoff game. Teams are only willing to give up so much for such a player.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Blue Jays have any interest in a Brendon Donovan/ Jojo Romero swap?
Mark Polishuk
Both would fit in Toronto, but the Jays have enough utility infield types that Donovan probably isn’t a priority (and especially not at the Cardinals’ asking price). Romero would be the better fit of the two.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pirates finished with 71 wins last year with barely any hitters over 100 wRC+. Adding in O'Hearn and Lowe should really help them. Could they realistically content for a WC spot and if not, what is holding them back?
Mark Polishuk
I think they’ve got a decent shot at a wild card as presently constructed. I’d like to see one more notable bat added to really spark things upwards, however.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Isn’t this a good time for Cards to rebuild – especially with the potential stoppage?
Mark Polishuk
Last year seemed like an even better team for the Cardinals to rebuild, yet they didn’t. Notwithstanding how their hands were tied by some no-trade clauses, it still makes me scratch my head about how even guys like Helsley, etc. weren’t dealt last winter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Chances Hoerner gets moved this offseason?
Mark Polishuk
Pretty low. The Cubs aren’t moving him unless they get a huge offer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How high of a ranked prospect will the Red Sox need to add to trade Yoshida?
Mark Polishuk
Considering those trades with the Cardinals, I wonder if the timing had worked out better (i.e. if Contreras had been more willing to waive his no-trade clause earlier), if Yoshida could’ve just been dealt to St. Louis as salary offset as part of a package for both Gray and Contreras. Probably still no, since while the Cards were eating money in the trades anyway, they still wanted players back.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see the Pirates moving Henry Davis or Endy Rodriguez to one of these catcher needy teams?
Mark Polishuk
Endy is the likelier of the two, just because the Pirates might not be able to bring themselves to move a 1-1 player just yet.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
SF Giant suggestion: trade Heliot Ramos and his horrible defense to STL for Donovan. Sign Bellinger and Bader to fix that outfield D, and still stay under the tax. Thoughts?
Mark Polishuk
Ramos probably isn’t the kind of player St. Louis is targeting in Donovan trade talks.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Seen some Cardinals fans hoping for Marcelo Mayer as part of a Brendan Donovan return. Unrealistic, no?
Mark Polishuk
Very.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
McCutcheon still wants to finish his career as a Pirate. Is he not worthy anymore?
Mark Polishuk
It’s tricky because Cutch is such a legend and so beloved in Pittsburgh. But in terms of what a player can produce in 2026 or how much playing time he should get, it’s tough to argue apart from pure sentiment that McCutchen should be part of a team serious about winning.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Feels like Padres are in a good spot to try and move Cronenworth with Hoerner/Marte both seeming unlikely to move.
Mark Polishuk
Cronenworth’s contract is a huge negative in trade talks. Hoerner is just for one year and Marte is a superstar, so they both have way more trade value.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Hoyer said at Cubs Con that they weren’t done yet. Bellinger?
Mark Polishuk
To be fair, it would’ve been pretty unlikely to see Hoyer stand up in front of a crowd of Cubs fans and announce “that’s it! I’m going on vacation!” and then run offstage with an overstuffed suitcase.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
As a Reds fan, I wouldn’t be on board with this, but I’ve seen multiple fellow Reds fans recommend dealing Brady Singer and Tyler Stephenson for Jarren Duran. Is that something Boston would even consider? Feels very light to me when you consider years of control and Duran’s ceiling.
Mark Polishuk
Boston definitely wants a lot more than that for Duran.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Andrew Vaughn is a free agent after this season. Do you think the Brewers resign him or let him walk?
Mark Polishuk
Probably let him walk. The Brewers aren’t likely to spend a significant amount on the first base position.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With a few hall of fame careers winding down, where does Jr Griffey place on your top 10-15 of all time list?
Mark Polishuk
I wouldn’t have Griffey in my top 10-15, but he’s not far outside that range.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Suppose the owners get their salary cap. What happens to contracts like Ohtani’s, Soto’s, etc? Would they be grandfathered in and the Dodgers and Mets would just be mostly unable to sign free agents until they come off the books?
Mark Polishuk
As noted earlier, if the MLBPA did somehow agree to any sort of a cap, it would be a soft cap with some sort of luxury tax still attached for overages. So depending on how stiff the penalties are, the Dodgers/Mets/etc. could decide they don’t really care about the penalties and keep spending big.
But, the league would certainly create a year or two of grace period for teams to get under this new cap.
-----------------------------------------------------------------