Page 1 of 1

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Posted: February 23 26, 4:42 pm
by mikechamp
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on February 22.

More questions than last week. You only get 2 bonus questions: one about OPS+ and one about the upcoming CBA, which will be a topic discussed for the next 12 months. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/mlbtr-liv ... 23909.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pirates are 3-0 in spring training. Are they the greatest team of all time??

Mark Polishuk
Yes. The next CBA will be built around how to level the competitive balance so powerhouse teams like Pittsburgh can be held in check.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Jesus Made debut this year?

Mark Polishuk
He doesn't turn 19 until May, though he has already gotten a handful of Double-A games under his belt. If he just crushes it in Double-A and Triple-A, I could see Milwaukee maybe giving him a cup of coffee in September, but a 2027 debut is probably likelier. The PPI will factor into the Brewers' decision, assuming that the PPI will continue to exist in some form in the next CBA.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Good job on the Brewers write up. You mention saves increase arbitration costs, does the fireman role make Megill more, less, or no difference in how likely they trade him in 26?

Mark Polishuk
Having saves on his resume means that Megill will still get a decent raise next winter if he's this year's closer or not. The Brewers might also be playing the long game in trying to limit Uribe's save totals, in order to prevent him from having too large a first-time price tag once he becomes arb-eligible.

All of this is next to the more obvious point that the Brewers are trying to win ballgames. However Megill or Uribe are utilized this season, Megill probably isn't being dealt until next winter, since the Crew usually move guys when they're a year away from free agency (not two, as Megill is now).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Out of Pages, Hererra, Crooks, and Pozo, who is the primary catcher and who DH’s?

Mark Polishuk
Herrera will catch as much as he can based on health and defensive capability, since he has a lot more value behind the plate than as a pure DH (even if he swings the bat well in any role).

Pages will probably be the primary backstop until the Cardinals have a better gauge on Herrera's situation, and the team will go from there. For some of the talk about the Cardinals trading from this on-paper surplus, that depth suddenly dries up quickly if Herrera can't really catch.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
How worrisome is it that the Cubs need to re-up with Nico, Seiya, Happ, Steele, Boyd, and Taillon?

Mark Polishuk
This is by design, since it feels like the Cubs are preparing for some changes to baseball's business structure in a new CBA. How widespread these changes are remains to be seen, and of course there's still a still a month of the 2026-27 offseason that will happen before the current CBA actually expires.

Steele, btw, is a free agent after 2027. The rest of the group are free agents after 2026.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which team has been the most surprising to go on a run that wasn't on anyone's radar throughout the season? Maybe 2006 Cards?

Mark Polishuk
Exactly nobody thought the 2023 World Series was going to wind up as Rangers vs. Diamondbacks, and yet...
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Have the Cubs done enough? Asking for a friend.

Mark Polishuk
Chicago should reach the postseason at the very least. Given how the Brewers took a step back on paper, winning the NL Central is certainly within the Cubs' reach.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I thought JoJo Romero would have been traded by now?

Mark Polishuk
Same here. Could easily still happen before Spring Training is over.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Brewers didn't take a step back. This is right where all the beat writers had them last year, too.

Mark Polishuk
Ah, that's why I said "on paper".
Milwaukee just keeps figuring out ways to win, no matter how many stars they trade.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What do you think of the job Bloom is doing in the Lou?

Mark Polishuk
Too early to tell, naturally. Felt like Bloom has been going for quantity of prospects over quality, with the Cards also eating a good deal of money to ensure that they have gotten some quality in return.

It'll be years before we can gauge Bloom's work properly, since so much of it depends on how the team drafts and develops, as well as future bigger-ticket moves like trades or signings.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Is a 102 ops+ really that much better than a 98 ops+ ?

Mark Polishuk
/Nigel Tufnel voice

Yeah, it's four better.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Jeff Passan thinks the history of the last time baseball was locked out will convince owners and players to compromise so that next season won't be lost. Do you think a salary minimum is a legitimate bargaining point from the MLBPA perspective when combined with a mild version of a salary cap? The teams that spend the least make quite a bit of money because they get the taxpayers' money. I don't like the idea of a salary cap because it will limit teams like the Yankees, Dodgers, Cubs, etc. from making the game exciting by creating great teams on paper. There is enough history to know that WS aren't won on paper.

Mark Polishuk
The MLBPA will resist a salary cap in any form. What's interesting about a cap is that it has to have a salary floor as well, which (if I recall the NFL/NBA/NHL versions) is something like 90% of the cap high.

If you're referring to the same Passan column I'm thinking of, Jeff made the point that a salary floor will lead to a lot of consternation amongst owners. Hypothetically, if a cap is something like $200MM, then an $180MM minimum spend isn't something the Pirates, Guardians, A's, Marlins, etc. are going to want to do.

So it creates a bit of a catch-22 situation for all parties. Plus there's also the fact that teams would have to give the MLBPA full access to their books in order to accurately gauge a cap or floor based on league revenues, and teams don't want to do that.
-----------------------------------------------------------------