Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments
Posted: March 2 26, 2:03 pm
These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on March 1.
About the same amount of questions as last week. There are 3 bonus questions, all about predictions/hypothetical situations. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/03/ ... t-111.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think we will see another early trade like we did with Priester last year? Teams like the Rays.. and well the Brewers seem to have a large glut of arms that can’t possible all fit and have talent waiting in the minors.
Mark Polishuk
It’s only March 1, so it would be unusual if there WASN’T at least one more prominent trade before Opening Day. All it takes is one injury to suddenly make a team more willing to shake up its roster.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any hope for McCutchen signing with ANYONE? Maybe he should go to Japan or Korea?
Mark Polishuk
Starling Marte’s deal may be a sign that teams are now starting to look closer at some of these veterans still on the market. A reunion with the Pirates seems less likely at this point, but Cutch can still land with a big league roster. Going overseas doesn’t seem to be in the cards at all.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who is more likely to extend Skenes or Griffin?
Mark Polishuk
Since there’s zero chance of a Skenes extension, Griffin is the answer by default. And to be fair, I could see the Bucs locking him up to a pre-career deal.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is Megill on the trade block or do the Brewers use he and Uribe as a one-two pinch in the closer role?
Mark Polishuk
Megill drew some trade interest earlier in the winter, but if he is dealt, it’ll probably be on the Brewers’ usual timeline of a year before free agency. So, Megill could be a popular trade chip next winter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on the Oli extension?
Mark Polishuk
The Cards are writing off the next couple of years anyway on a rebuild, so it makes for them to stick with a familiar (and trusted) voice in the dugout.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Very slim chance the Brewers are willing to pay up for a Contreras extension. Do you see them trading him next offseason like they’ve done with Burnes and Peralta?
Mark Polishuk
Very likely, which is why Jeferson Quero is a real intriguing player to watch for Milwaukee fans.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on the approach to trades from Craig Breslow, he made like 14 trades but refused to trade from his top 5 prospects and didn’t deal Mayer or Duran or any other big MLB talent. Dealing away substantial quantity vs the top trade chips, does this seem like a good plan or should Craig have been willing to pay for an established star?
Mark Polishuk
Based on just this offseason, I think the Sox have done quite well to add talent without giving up much in return. In the multiple Cardinals trades, for instance, just taking on extra money helped the Red Sox add Gray/Contreras for only okay returns going back in the Cardinals’ direction.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What do think the Cubs do to back up 1st base?
Mark Polishuk
Giving Matt Shaw a few looks might not be a bad shout, as he matches nicely as a platoon with Busch. Or, if not a true regular platoon, he can get some starts at 1B against lefties to spell Busch.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Hi. Thanks for the chat. On a STL chat forum peoples heads are exploding with Oli’s extension. Is he really that bad a manager or has the lack of talent been the primary problem?
Mark Polishuk
Marmol is hard to evaluate. Like with any manager, a lot of his work is done behind the scenes, plus he took over the Cardinals during a time when either the team was nearing the end of a competitive cycle, or the player development team was having more issues churning out prospects.
I can’t say I’ve been particularly wowed by Marmol’s work as a manager, but the fact that the team stuck by him through the Cards’ struggles tells me that the organization trusts him. It would’ve been very easy to fire Marmol and make him the scapegoat, but both Mozeliak and now Bloom view him as their choice in the dugout.
Also, this is just my read from afar on the St. Louis fanbase, but it also seems like the Cards fans give Marmol less leeway because they keep expecting Pujols or Molina to eventually take over as manager.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who are your MVP picks if you can't choose Othani or Judge?
Mark Polishuk
Fun question! Let’s say Jose Ramirez in the AL, and a spite-fueled Bryce Harper in the NL.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would you rather have 10 straight division titles or 1 World Series win?
Mark Polishuk
A World Series win
Put it this way….my favorite football team is the Packers. They’ve won the NFC North a bunch of times, and suffered a bunch of gut-wrenching playoff losses. But, because they’ve won two Super Bowls during my fandom, those championships help make up for a lot of other playoff pain.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who are your Cy Young picks if you can’t choose Skubal, Crochet, Skenes or Yamamoto?
Mark Polishuk
Hunter Brown, Freddy Peralta
-----------------------------------------------------------------
About the same amount of questions as last week. There are 3 bonus questions, all about predictions/hypothetical situations. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/03/ ... t-111.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think we will see another early trade like we did with Priester last year? Teams like the Rays.. and well the Brewers seem to have a large glut of arms that can’t possible all fit and have talent waiting in the minors.
Mark Polishuk
It’s only March 1, so it would be unusual if there WASN’T at least one more prominent trade before Opening Day. All it takes is one injury to suddenly make a team more willing to shake up its roster.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Any hope for McCutchen signing with ANYONE? Maybe he should go to Japan or Korea?
Mark Polishuk
Starling Marte’s deal may be a sign that teams are now starting to look closer at some of these veterans still on the market. A reunion with the Pirates seems less likely at this point, but Cutch can still land with a big league roster. Going overseas doesn’t seem to be in the cards at all.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who is more likely to extend Skenes or Griffin?
Mark Polishuk
Since there’s zero chance of a Skenes extension, Griffin is the answer by default. And to be fair, I could see the Bucs locking him up to a pre-career deal.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is Megill on the trade block or do the Brewers use he and Uribe as a one-two pinch in the closer role?
Mark Polishuk
Megill drew some trade interest earlier in the winter, but if he is dealt, it’ll probably be on the Brewers’ usual timeline of a year before free agency. So, Megill could be a popular trade chip next winter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on the Oli extension?
Mark Polishuk
The Cards are writing off the next couple of years anyway on a rebuild, so it makes for them to stick with a familiar (and trusted) voice in the dugout.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Very slim chance the Brewers are willing to pay up for a Contreras extension. Do you see them trading him next offseason like they’ve done with Burnes and Peralta?
Mark Polishuk
Very likely, which is why Jeferson Quero is a real intriguing player to watch for Milwaukee fans.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Thoughts on the approach to trades from Craig Breslow, he made like 14 trades but refused to trade from his top 5 prospects and didn’t deal Mayer or Duran or any other big MLB talent. Dealing away substantial quantity vs the top trade chips, does this seem like a good plan or should Craig have been willing to pay for an established star?
Mark Polishuk
Based on just this offseason, I think the Sox have done quite well to add talent without giving up much in return. In the multiple Cardinals trades, for instance, just taking on extra money helped the Red Sox add Gray/Contreras for only okay returns going back in the Cardinals’ direction.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What do think the Cubs do to back up 1st base?
Mark Polishuk
Giving Matt Shaw a few looks might not be a bad shout, as he matches nicely as a platoon with Busch. Or, if not a true regular platoon, he can get some starts at 1B against lefties to spell Busch.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Hi. Thanks for the chat. On a STL chat forum peoples heads are exploding with Oli’s extension. Is he really that bad a manager or has the lack of talent been the primary problem?
Mark Polishuk
Marmol is hard to evaluate. Like with any manager, a lot of his work is done behind the scenes, plus he took over the Cardinals during a time when either the team was nearing the end of a competitive cycle, or the player development team was having more issues churning out prospects.
I can’t say I’ve been particularly wowed by Marmol’s work as a manager, but the fact that the team stuck by him through the Cards’ struggles tells me that the organization trusts him. It would’ve been very easy to fire Marmol and make him the scapegoat, but both Mozeliak and now Bloom view him as their choice in the dugout.
Also, this is just my read from afar on the St. Louis fanbase, but it also seems like the Cards fans give Marmol less leeway because they keep expecting Pujols or Molina to eventually take over as manager.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who are your MVP picks if you can't choose Othani or Judge?
Mark Polishuk
Fun question! Let’s say Jose Ramirez in the AL, and a spite-fueled Bryce Harper in the NL.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would you rather have 10 straight division titles or 1 World Series win?
Mark Polishuk
A World Series win
Put it this way….my favorite football team is the Packers. They’ve won the NFC North a bunch of times, and suffered a bunch of gut-wrenching playoff losses. But, because they’ve won two Super Bowls during my fandom, those championships help make up for a lot of other playoff pain.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who are your Cy Young picks if you can’t choose Skubal, Crochet, Skenes or Yamamoto?
Mark Polishuk
Hunter Brown, Freddy Peralta
-----------------------------------------------------------------